Emerald vs Diamond: Which is More Valuable?

Emerald vs Diamond: Diamonds and emeralds are two of the most beloved gemstones in the world, captivating our imaginations with their dazzling colours and unique properties. But when it comes to value, which reigns supreme? Is it the coveted diamond with its brilliant sparkle or the rich green emerald steeped in history and symbolism?

In this blog post, we’ll delve into the centuries-old debate over emerald vs. diamond – exploring everything from rarity and durability to cultural significance – so you can decide for yourself which precious stone is truly more valuable. So buckle up—we’re about to take a glittering journey through the fascinating world of gemstones.

The History and Significance of Emerald Vs Diamond

Emeralds have been treasured throughout history for their brilliant green colour. Some of the earliest references to emeralds date back to the 4th century BC when they were first discovered in Egypt. Since then, these beautiful stones have been used in everything from jewellery to artwork.

Diamonds, on the other hand, are best known for their hardness and Sparkle. They have been used as gemstones for centuries and are prized for their beauty. However, it wasn’t until the late 19th century that diamonds became more widely available.

So, which is more valuable? It depends on a number of factors, including rarity, demand, and market conditions. In general, however, emeralds are more valuable than diamonds.

Emerald Vs Diamond Cost

When it comes to a cost comparison, emeralds are often more expensive than diamonds. For instance, a one-carat emerald can cost around $1,000 while a one-carat diamond of the same size may only cost $600. However, this does not mean that emeralds are always more valuable than diamonds. In fact, the value of diamonds tends to be much higher than that of emeralds. Here is a breakdown of the emerald vs diamond price:

  • Size: When comparing the value of emeralds vs diamonds, size is an important factor to consider. Emeralds are typically larger in size than diamonds, which means they weigh more. This makes them rare and therefore, more valuable.
  • Clarity: Another factor that contributes to the value of emeralds vs diamonds is clarity. Emeralds tend to be less clear than diamonds, which means they have more flaws and inclusions. This makes them less valuable than their diamond counterparts.
  • Colour: The final factor to consider when determining the value of emeralds vs diamonds is colour. Emeralds are typically green in colour while diamonds can be found in a variety of colours (including pink, blue, and yellow). The green colour of emeralds makes them rare and therefore, more valuable.

Quality Comparison of Emerald vs Diamond: Evaluating the Cut, Clarity and Colour of

When it comes to emeralds and diamonds, both have unique qualities that make them valuable. However, when comparing the two stones side-by-side, there are some clear distinctions. Here is a quality comparison of emeralds and diamonds, based on the cut, clarity and colour:

Cut: When it comes to the cut of emeralds and diamonds, both stones can be cut into a variety of shapes and sizes. However, due to the hardness of diamonds, they can be cut with much more precision than emeralds. This results in a diamond having more symmetry and a more polished look overall.

Clarity: In terms of clarity, emeralds are often included with many small imperfections called “Jardin” (French for the garden). These imperfections actually add to the value of an emerald since they are so rare. Diamonds, on the other hand, are graded on a scale from flawless (no inclusions) to Included (heavy inclusions). The clearer a diamond is, the more rare and valuable it is.

Colour: When it comes to colour, emeralds range in hue from green to blue-green. The most valuable emeralds are those with a pure green hue. Diamonds come in a variety of colours, but the most valuable are those that are completely colourless or near colourless.

Hardness10 on the Mohs scale7.5 on the Mohs scale
ColorClear, colorlessGreen
InclusionsFew inclusionsMore likely to have inclusions
CutBrilliant cutCabochon or step cut
ValueVaries depending on qualityVaries depending on quality

Wearability Comparison of Emerald vs Diamond: Durability and Versatility

Emeralds are generally more durable than diamonds, but they are also more brittle. This means that they are more likely to crack or chip if they are hit hard enough. However, emeralds can be cut and polished to a high degree of clarity and refraction, making them very versatile stones.

Diamonds, on the other hand, are the hardest natural material on Earth. This makes them highly durable, but also means that they are less likely to show the colour and brilliance of an emerald. Diamonds can also be cut and polished to a high degree of clarity and refraction, making them just as versatile as emeralds.

Investment Potential of Each Stone: Emerald vs Diamond

The investment potential of each stone depends on a number of factors, including the rarity of the stone, its colour, clarity, and cut.

Emeralds are typically rare than diamonds, and thus have greater potential as an investment. However, diamonds are often seen as a safer investment because they are more durable and their value is less likely to fluctuate.

Colour is also a major factor in the investment potential of a stone. For example, pink diamonds are very rare and thus can be quite valuable. Clarity is another important factor, as stones with few imperfections are usually more desirable and thus worth more money. Finally, the cut of a stone can affect its value; well-cut stones are usually more expensive than those that are not cut as well.

Alternatives to Emeralds & Diamonds

If you’re looking for an alternative to emeralds or diamonds, there are plenty of options out there. Here are a few of the most popular:

Rubies: Rubies are a red variety of corundum, and they’re one of the hardest minerals on earth (second only to diamonds). They’re also very durable and have excellent clarity. Like emeralds, they’re relatively rare and command high prices.

Sapphires: Sapphires are another variety of corundum, and they come in a wide range of colours (not just blue). They’re also durable and have excellent clarity. And like rubies and emeralds, they’re quite rare and therefore can be quite expensive.

Opals: Opals are unique among gemstones because they don’t have a crystal structure. instead, they consist of tiny spheres of silica that diffract light to create a beautiful “play of colour.” They come in a wide range of colours and can be very striking. However, they’re relatively soft and not as durable as diamonds, emeralds, or rubies.

Pearls: Pearls are produced by certain molluscs when an irritant gets lodged inside their shell. Over time, the mollusc secretes nacre around the irritant until it’s completely covered. Pearl quality depends on several factors, including the type of mollusc, the size


Which is better, diamond or emerald?

It depends on your personal preference and what you are looking for. Diamonds are known for their hardness and durability, making them a popular choice for engagement rings and other jewellery that is worn frequently. Emeralds, on the other hand, are known for their unique green colour and are often chosen for their beauty and rarity.

Are emeralds more valuable than diamonds?

Not necessarily. The value of a gemstone depends on several factors, including its rarity, colour, clarity, and carat weight. While emeralds can be quite valuable, diamonds are generally considered to be more valuable due to their hardness, brilliance, and overall popularity.

What is more expensive than an emerald?

There are several gemstones that are generally more expensive than emeralds. For example, rubies and sapphires are both considered to be more valuable due to their rarity and intense colour. Some rare types of garnet, spinel, and tourmaline can also be more expensive than emeralds.

What is the difference between green diamond and emerald?

The main difference between green diamonds and emeralds is their chemical composition. Emeralds are a type of beryl mineral that contains chromium and vanadium, which give them their characteristic green colour. Green diamonds, on the other hand, get their colour from natural radiation exposure during their formation. Green diamonds are extremely rare and valuable, while emeralds are more common but still highly prized for their beauty.

Is emerald expensive than diamond?

Emerald is more expensive than diamond. This is because emeralds are rarer and more difficult to cut and polish. However, the price of an emerald can vary greatly depending on its quality, color, clarity, and cut. A high-quality emerald with a vivid green color and few inclusions can be much more expensive than a diamond of the same carat weight.

Are green diamonds radioactive??

Green diamonds can be radioactive, but not all of them are. The green colour in a diamond can be caused by either natural or artificial irradiation. Natural irradiation occurs when a diamond is exposed to radioactive minerals or fluids in nature. Artificial irradiation is when a diamond is exposed to radiation in a laboratory.


Emeralds and diamonds are both beautiful gemstones that represent a classic aesthetic. But when it comes to value, emeralds tend to be more valuable than diamonds due to their rarity, deep colouring, and underlying mystique. While diamond prices fluctuate according to the four C’s (clarity, cut, colour and carat weight), emerald prices remain relatively stable due to their popularity as an investment stone. If you decide to invest your money in stones whether it is by purchasing either a diamond or an emerald make sure you do your research.

Also explore green onyx stone vs emerald, how to choose the right emerald stone, how to care for an emerald stone and many more at Emerald Stone Online.

Jyotish Varsha Gupta
Varsha Gupta


Leave a Comment